Correspondence on Verizon Outage - July 2011

Letter from GCA

Glencarlyn Citizens' Association

Arlington Virginia

September 5, 2100

Federal Communications Commission

Consumer & Governmental Affairs Bureau

Consumer Complaints

445 12th Street, SW

Washington, D.C. 20554

fccinfo@fcc.gov

 

Dear Sir:

The Executive Committee of the Glencarlyn Citizens' Association has been asked to prepare a consolidated response on behalf of a number of residents in our community of 540 homes who are Verizon land line customers.  Many, we are not sure what percentage, lost service for up to a week as a result of a line failure outside of our community on Monday, July 11, 2011.  Our community is in Arlington Virginia, 22204 between Arlington Blvd on the north, Harrison St  on the east, Montana on the west and 5th Road on the south.

The officers of the Association, which represent this area, received a number of  calls and emails from residents regarding this event.  The major concerns were:

· Very poor communication

· Customers calling for service were not given consistent or complete information on what caused the problem and what the logistics would be involved in correcting it.

· Customers were given project completion dates that were not met.  Extensions to the time were added without useful explanations.

· Customers received robocalls that the service was restored when it was not.

· Customers talking to service crews were often given incorrect or conflicting information.

· Service call staff indicated that they would call back daily but never did.

· One resident's series of calls made it clear that the problem resolution manager was clearly on a different page than the area manager on what was happening and when things would be done.

· Length of time to resolve the issue

· We know of some customers who did not have service restored until Sunday, July 17, seven days without service.  Some had service restored earlier, however, we understand there may be  some customers who did not have service restored until after Sunday.

· Please note that the outage was caused by a vehicle hitting equipment not storm damage in multiple locations.

· Phone service is a utility, like electricity and water.  Customers expect the service to be restored quickly when problems occur, particularly when the outage is not part of major natural event.

· A resident was told the repair crews do not work at night, which is obviously a customer concern during an outage of this type.

· A number of our residents work from home, so the phone and internet outage was an income hardship, not just a significant personal inconvenience.  At least one had to purchase a smartphone to be able to continue business.

 

Understandably, there is considerable frustration among all of the customers. There were a number of other comments made in the emails we received, both about this outage and other frustrations.  We have attached the full email from each customer for your information.

We appreciate your attention to this matter and hope that Verizon handles both the speed of restoring service more quickly and that the poor communication with the customers is improved.  If you have any questions, please contact Peter Olivere at president_gca@glencarlyn.org or 703-626-2520.

 

                                                                              Sincerely,

            

                                                                              Peter Olivere

                                                                              President

                                                                              Glencarlyn Citizens' Association

 

Attachment

 

cc:    William Irby, Director

         Division of Communications

         Virginia, State Corporation Commission

         communications@scc.virginia.gov

 

         Christopher Zimmerman

        Chair, Arlington County Board

        countyboard@arlingtonva.us

 

PDF version of the letter with attachment — 5 pages of comments from residents

Email from the Virginia State Corporation Commission

From: Gladys Huddleston <Gladys.Huddleston@scc.virginia.gov>

To: 'president_gca@glencarlyn.org' <president_gca@glencarlyn.org>

Subject: SCC Verizon Complaint

Date: Thu, Sep 29, 2011 5:56 pm

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

Mr. Olivere,

 

This is in response to your complaint filed in our office on September 6, 2011 against Verizon Virginia.

 

According to Verizon, a local manager has contacted you to explain the magnitude of replacing a 2100 and 400 pair cable.  Per the manager, the cable had to be spliced together before customers would begin to regain their service.  The damage to the cable was done on July 11, 2011, however Verizon could not begin restoration until the power company had replaced the damaged pole.  The pole was replaced on July 12, 2011 and Verizon started their work that same afternoon and the work was completed on July 15, 2011.  Based on Verizon’s response, this complaint has been closed.  If you are still experiencing telephone issues,  or if additional problems arise, do not hesitate to contact our office for further assistance.

 

I would like to thank you for allowing me to assist you with your complaint.

 

Respectfully, 

 

Gladys Huddleston

Telecommunications Specialist

SCC

gladys.huddleston@SCC.virginia.gov

(804) 371-9420

Material included on this page:

Description of the Verizon Outage in November Village View

Email from the Virginia State Corporation Commission

GCA Response to September 29 email from SCC

Letter from Verizon October 14

Letter from Verizon October 14

Verizon National Customer Relations

13100 Columbia Pike

Silver Spring MD 20904

 

October 14, 2011

 

Giencarlyn Citizens Association

Arlington Virginia

 

RE:  Delayed Verizon Service restoral

 

Mr. Olivere:

Thank you for your recent communication with the Virginia State Corporation Commission concerning the delay in restoring services to your community.

First, I would like to apologize on behalf of Verizon for the inconvenience and frustration this matter has caused. In reviewing the situation I found the outage began July 11, 2011 when the line was taken down by a passing truck. Verizon was unable to begin restoration until the power company replaced a pole which was done on July 12th. We began our work that afternoon and closed the ticket July 15th.

Please be advised as each customer calls to report a trouble, the information is entered for their respective service and the next available date is given based off the availability of a technician. The initial representative is unable to determine if a particular customer is part of a larger outage, as that is something our systems do after the ticket is submitted. As the system tracks the tickets, it associates them accordingly and groups them in an effort to restore customer’s services in the most efficient way possible.

Again we apologize for the inconvenience and frustration this process may have caused and assure you we work diligently to restore all services as soon as possible.

 

Sincerely,

 

Lisa Morse

Verizon Customer Advocacy

 

Cc: Virginia State Corporation Commission

 

PDF scan of the letter from Verizon

Description of the Verizon Outage in November 2011 Village View

The letter the GCA sent to the Virginia State Corporation Commission (VSCC) regarding the several day Verizon outage in July and the poor communication to the customers is on the website. Since then we received a letter from the VSCC in which they affirm that a local manager has contacted the GCA to explain the magnitude of the repair.  A trash truck hit and broke two overhead Verizon major cables.  One had 2100 pairs of wires and the other had 400 pair.  This means that up to 2500 phone lines were taken out of service. 

The damage to the cable was done on July 11, 2011, however Verizon could not begin restoration until the power company had replaced the damaged pole. The pole was replaced on July 12, 2011 and Verizon started their work that same afternoon. The work required the insertion of a new section of cable, with each of the 5,000 wires (2500 pairs) being spliced on each end. Teams worked on the repair continually in 12 hour shifts.  The work was coordinated so that the splices for each pair for a phone line were done together then checked.  This is why phone service was house by house over several days.  According to Verizon, the work was completed on July 15, 2011. Although Verizon’s wanted this response, to close the complaint, we took exception and requested that they address the incorrect and incomplete information which was provided to the customers.  We expect to hear back on that soon.

GCA Response to September 29 email from SCC

 

Ms Huddleston

The complaint focused a much on the terrible communications by Verizon with incomplete and misleading information given. As far as we are concerned the complaint is still open. We are hoping the SCC would respect our request for a response on what is being done to address the issue of communications which was presented in considerable detail in the letter sent on behalf of the community.

This chronic lack of useful communications continued to the first call I got from the Verizon local manager, who when he called asked if I wanted to know about the brief outage a day or so before. He had not even looked at the transmittal letter of any of the attachments. I asked him to look at the material we sent and call back.

He called back several days later with a lot of information about the technical issues which was very useful. At the end of the second call I asked for a written response from Verizon to the SCC, with a copy to us, about the terrible communications during this outage and what Verizon were doing to fix it. So far we have heard nothing on that issue.

I hope that the SCC pursues this issue with Verizon of communication with customers and requires them to do a better job in the future. I expect to hear back from you once Verizon has responded to that part of the complaint.

 

Thank you.

Peter Olivere

President, Glencarlyn Citizens' Association.

703-626-2520